Current Fav List - Chapter 4


Back to topics list
[post:380#3395]
Jan-Chan

04/02/2009 10:00 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

WELL .. TIS THAT TIME AGAIN ... ALMOST ALL OF OUR POPULAR FAV SERIES HAVE ENDED ... SO WHAT SHOULD WE ADD NOW????

Current guidelines ...

  • The intent is to provide an easy click space for visitors to access new series (or titles).
  • Titles must be currently airing in Japan (or the pacific rim) or being fansubbed.
  • Once licensed, the title should be removed from the list.
  • Once a title completes airing overseas and being fansubbed, it should be removed within a week.
  • Titles shall be decided by popular vote as presented and discussed in the forum.
  • If two senior reviewers are in agreement, then a title can be added.
Linkboxes

Current Favorites (as of April 3rd '09)

[post:380#3402]
Forbin

04/03/2009 01:04 PM

Reviews: 478
Posts: 532

Do NOT ADD Queen's Blade...aka Girls with Big boobies who use their milk to shoot at each other....(Got you want to see it eh?)

BTW Yoichi is over isn't it? So is Index and Clannad. Index's sequel is starting up about Mikoto.

Edited on 04/03/2009 01:05 PM.

[post:380#3403]
Jan-Chan

04/03/2009 03:23 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

Dern .. I was hoping that Yoichi was a 24/26ep series.

Well ... me just might to have to add Queen's Blade (just to keep dem boyz quiet!!).

K-ON! seems to hold a lot of promise.... (it reminds me of Minami-ke or Hyakko).

Here is a quick peek of what we can look forward to this month .. compliments of ANIDB

Edited on 04/03/2009 07:01 PM.

[post:380#3405]
Stretch

04/03/2009 06:41 PM

Reviews: 2087
Posts: 1346

Where is everybody getting Queen's Blade from? Neither AnimeSuki nor Tokyo Toshokan have it. YouTube is supposed to have it, but there seems to be all sorts of bands by that name, and brief promos & previews, but I can't find episode one itself. Any help would be appreciated. It sounds too bad to pass up.

[post:380#3406]
Jan-Chan

04/03/2009 06:59 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

Ya can find it as a torrent at T-Tosh or you can look here at VEOH

[post:380#3407]
Stretch

04/03/2009 07:21 PM

Reviews: 2087
Posts: 1346

Jeez, I went looking at Toshokan for Queen's Blade, and Queens' Blade, but they had it as just plain Queens Blade! Thanks, Jan-chan!

[post:380#3409]
Forbin

04/03/2009 09:55 PM

Reviews: 478
Posts: 532

HAHAHAHAHA Gulgtra put it up!

[post:380#3410]
Jan-Chan

04/03/2009 10:01 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

TX .... Gulgtra!!! (teee!! heee!!)

Edited on 04/03/2009 10:03 PM.

[post:380#3411]
AstroNerdBoy

04/04/2009 05:46 AM

Reviews: 419
Posts: 398

Clannad After Story has ended as well. White Album will be back this winter though. I haven't heard if it will get a new name or just continue on. I'm hoping for the later but that's generally not how the Japanese work.

[post:380#3412]
Jan-Chan

04/04/2009 01:01 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

I have been taking some liberties in adding a few new titles to the Current Fav List. My intent is to keep things interesting, so feel free to criticize some of my selections or make changes to the list if needed.

[post:380#3415]
Xenoknight

04/05/2009 04:26 AM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

I've been on my Xbox for far too long these days. What happened to the list... well.... it really doesn't matter since all those titles were done anyway.

Before removing all those good titles, you could've taken out Casshern sins (at least). It has been on there for too long now.

I don't know about K-on but let's see the first couple of eps.

Queen's Blade is obviously going to be the lead title on the list. I just hope it's not ENTIRELY an ecchi fest and there is some other redeeming qualities in there. I'm dying to see the first ep after what Jan-Chan wrote about it in his review. (^_^) LOL

I still have reviews to write for the previous list of titles. I'm drowning in a sea of anime at this point. Somebody help me... LOL

[post:380#3417]
Xenoknight

04/06/2009 02:03 AM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

Hey Jan-Chan,

Whatever happened to at least two senior agreements for additions. Your moving too fast.

[post:380#3418]
Jan-Chan

04/06/2009 02:49 AM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

Yes ... I am moving fast .. but, did you notice that of the list presented at the top of this column, EVERY SINGLE ANIME SERIES EXPIRED!! BAAAAAAH!!! (Regios excepted)

So I am tossing on the new series as they come, and then we can stomp on any of the non-performing titles and replace them with better ones.

I even went so far as to add Booby Blade because I knew that you (and a few others) would probably would like to see it on the list. (Pls forgive, but it might not be one of my choices)

Pls keep in mind that the list is intended to garner the attention of casual visitors ... and I will be posting some review updates to all of the series that I add to the list. And we can always make changes.

Edited on 04/07/2009 11:46 AM.

[post:380#3419]
Xenoknight

04/07/2009 08:24 AM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

fair enough.

[post:380#3420]
Jan-Chan

04/07/2009 11:39 AM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

HUMMMMM ... it appears as if we have a trio of dark supernatural stories this season. I don't know if they are any good or if they will be able to carry their own weight as the stories progress, but we can always drop any titles prove to be doggy or go rabbit.

Asura Cryin', Pandora Hearts and 07-Ghost

[post:380#3421]
Xenoknight

04/07/2009 11:44 AM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

From my "empty reviews", I remember saying that I would love to see O7-Ghost and Pandora Hearts. I'll stand by those titles for now I guess.

What was the limit to the list again? 13 or so?

I'm probably going to want to ask everyone about Tayutama: Kiss on my Deity sooner or later. It's cute, has action potential, and let's not forget - harem! It's probably still too early for that one though.

Edited on 04/07/2009 11:54 AM.

[post:380#3428]
chibi

04/07/2009 01:42 PM

Reviews: 100
Posts: 9

I gave up on Queen's Blade halfway through the first episode. Somebody tell me I'm wrong, 'cause I won't waste any more time on it.

I predict Tayutama is going to be a romp -- fun, but nothing significant.

Edited on 04/07/2009 01:47 PM.

[post:380#3438]
Stretch

04/09/2009 11:27 AM

Reviews: 2087
Posts: 1346

I've only seen half of the raw version of episode one of Tayutama, but it looks pretty good and probably has as much, if not more, justification to be added to the list as any other title there.

Along with Regios, another continuing winter series which I'm enjoying is Sora Kake Girl. Is anybody else watching it?

[post:380#3439]
Forbin

04/09/2009 12:35 PM

Reviews: 478
Posts: 532

I need to get in to Sora kake, it got sorta bumped by Munto2 since they share almost the same name. Is it good?

[post:380#3440]
Stretch

04/09/2009 01:48 PM

Reviews: 2087
Posts: 1346

Sora Kake is... weird. It just takes all sorts of strange cliches and runs with them. A superintelligent computer that is vain and arrogant; a Rei-clone who serves him; A Policewoman who is trying to make sense of it all; two more policewomen, from another, competing, branch of the government, who are continually getting crapped on by their superiors; Yet another supercomputer who hates the first one; his evil minions; some girl (apparently) who is sealed in a box and refuses to come out; strange, Pillsbury dough-boy like aliens (or robots?); hightech spacecraft; etcetera. In short, all sorts of weirdness rolled together. Be advised that it's very confusing at first.

[post:380#3493]
Xenoknight

06/05/2009 07:25 PM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

I was just about to hit restore on the current favs and noticed some mistakes that weren't corrected, so I guess we have to debate on what is worthy or not as per the new list and previous guidelines.

New titles on list:

N1-Cross Game
N2-K-ON!
N3-Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu 2009

Titles that were unjustly removed:

U1-Tears to Tiara
U2-Phantom ~Requiem for the Phantom~
U3-Senjou no Valkyria Gallian Chronicles
U4-Higashi no Eden

The current guidelines are:

*The intent is to provide an easy click space for visitors to access new series (or titles).
*Titles must be currently airing in Japan (or the pacific rim) or being fansubbed.
*Once licensed, the title should be removed from the list.
*Once a title completes airing overseas and being fansubbed, it should be removed within a week.
*Titles shall be decided by popular vote as presented and discussed in the forum.
*If two senior reviewers are in agreement, then a title can be added.

The list is to be sorted by (also can be used as "title removal criteria"):

*General potential - arguable
*Enthusiasm by senior reviewers - arguable
*Frequency of updates

By those guidelines, I say:

Cross Game - should stay
K-ON! - should be removed
Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu 2009 - can go either way - needs votes
Phantom ~Requiem for the Phantom~ - should stay off
Senjou no Valkyria Gallian Chronicles - can go either way - needs votes
Higashi no Eden - should return
Tears to Tiara - should return - if not, then we need to add something about "reviewer resigning" to the current guidelines

Any comments before the changes are made...

Edited on 06/05/2009 07:44 PM.

[post:380#3494]
Stretch

06/05/2009 08:05 PM

Reviews: 2087
Posts: 1346

I am currently watching N1-N3, but U4 is the only unjustly removed title which I'm viewing. I gave up on U1 and U3 after one episode, and have shelved U3 after six (I'm still downloading it, but have lost interest and may never actually watch the rest).

[post:380#3495]
Jan-Chan

06/05/2009 08:33 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

Sorry ... sorry .... sorry .....

We had a situation where someone edited the FAV LIST and removed some 60% of the titles and added KIBA and one other older title.

I tried to put back the list as best as I could remember .... but I might have been a bit sloppy.

My comments on XenoKnights suggestions are ...

Cross Game - Keep
K-On - While I like it, I have mixed feelings
Haruhi 2 - Keep
Phantom - off the list
Valkyia - mixed fillings
Higashi No Eden - Keep on the list
Tears to Tiara - mixed ....


In short .. I am supporting XenoKnights recommended updates and changes...

[post:380#3496]
Xenoknight

06/05/2009 09:08 PM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

Done.

[post:380#3505]
Forbin

06/11/2009 02:45 PM

Reviews: 478
Posts: 532

ok who dared remove K-On.

[post:380#3506]
Stretch

06/11/2009 03:18 PM

Reviews: 2087
Posts: 1346

Yeah, I would say that K-ON is definitely superior to something like half of the titles still on the list, and gives almost all of them a run for their money.

[post:380#3507]
Forbin

06/11/2009 06:22 PM

Reviews: 478
Posts: 532

Here's what I am watching

  • K-On - It's just funny
  • Hayate - Focuses on Hayate x (Any of his harem)
  • Regios - Getting weird but will stick it out.
  • Haruhi 2 - BEST OF THE BUNCH
  • Hatsukoi - JC Staff Excellence.
I am watching others like Tears and Natsu, but they don't compare to the above list.

[post:380#3508]
Xenoknight

06/12/2009 12:35 AM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

That's cool. I thought that change of mine was too easy. LOL

According to past updates, it seems like nobody is watching K-on. When a series goes about a month without an update, it just makes me wonder. Only recently did you guys put up an update for it. Let's try to keep our favorite titles fresh with updates for the casual visitor to see. That's how I feel at least.

Here are some other titles that are about to become "end-of-life":

Senjou no Valkyria Gallian Chronicles
Asura Cryin'
Hagane no Renkinjutsushi - FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST - just saved by Silence
Hayate no Gotoku !! - just saved by Forbin


Knock, knock - hello... Is anyone out there still watching/enjoying these titles?

We can argue all day about those titles above even having a chance of coming close to Tears to Tiara, but I'd rather not. As for the rumor central that is Haruhi, I would say it has the potential to be as good as the first season. As of right now, it's still trying to dust itself off after nearly being cancelled so maybe it is too soon to praise Haruhi for anything at this point in time. That's what I want to say anyway, but even I know when to pick my battles and that is why I put Haruhi first on the list regardless of how I feel about it.

As per our rules, K-on will be added by two senior reviewers in agreement.

Edited on 06/12/2009 01:13 AM.

[post:380#3510]
Violet D

06/16/2009 02:03 PM

Reviews: 131
Posts: 57

Hey I still want to go by the list you guys have down. I still want to see K-ON. There are still lots I haven't seen. Just busy with other things I guess. But I'm always checking out new anime and even our libray gets some every now and then. As always you guys have a great day. Your, Violet D

[post:380#3511]
Jan-Chan

06/16/2009 02:32 PM

Reviews: 599
Posts: 593

Hey ... Xenobop...

Hayate and FMA ....

Both first seasons of these two titles were 52-episodes long (and some people even claim that Hayate-1 is actually 4x13ep seasons).

I know that FMA will be 52ep long, and I don't know about Hayate, but I suspect that it will be 52 also ...

Here is what we can expect in July '09 in terms of new titles....

[post:380#3512]
Xenoknight

06/17/2009 02:37 PM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

So we have some long titles in the works. That's fine.

As for the new titles next "anime season":

Aoi Hana
Needless
Princess Lover!
Ookami to Koushinryou 2nd Series
Yoku Wakaru Gendai Mahou


Those titles catch my eye right from the jump. I like some other titles but only time will tell with those.

PS: What's with the nick names?

[post:380#3513]
Xenoknight

06/17/2009 02:44 PM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

So we have some long titles in the works. That's fine.

As for the new "anime season":

Aoi Hana
Needless
Bakemonogatari
Princess Lover!
Ookami to Koushinryou 2nd Series
Yoku Wakaru Gendai Mahou


These titles spike my anime senses. I like some other ones too, but only time will tell.

PS: What is with the weird nick names? XK was fine by me.

Edited on 06/17/2009 02:44 PM.

[post:380#3514]
Xenoknight

06/17/2009 03:02 PM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

In regards to the duplicated post 3512 and 3513:

I finally see what's been happening to Violet. We've seen it happening to her quite a bit lately.

The server gave me an error and told me to refresh the page but deleted my first message, so I wrote it again and now there are two.

I'll leave the first one so Rebecca can see it if they want to fix this server error.

[post:380#3525]
Xenoknight

07/01/2009 09:54 AM

Reviews: 244
Posts: 514

It happened again with chapter 5...

The server duplicated the forum posts.

Reply to this topic Start a new topic
Back to topics list

Community Anime Reviews

anime mikomi org